Jesse Mathews Pleads Guilty To Chapin Slaying; Gets Life In Prison Without Parole

Friday, November 30, 2012
Jesse Mathews in front of Judge Barry Steelman
Jesse Mathews in front of Judge Barry Steelman
- photo by Brent McDonald (See video on NewsChannel 9)

Jesse Mathews pleaded guilty on Friday afternoon to killing Chattanooga Police Sgt. Tim Chapin.

He was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole after pleading guilty to six different charges - first-degree murder, felony murder, three counts of attempted first-degree murder and aggravated robbery. He received an additional 25 years beyond the life sentence.

The state had been seeking the death penalty against him.

Mathews gave up all of his appeal rights.

Judge Barry Steelman asked Mathews if he understood that the pleas meant "life in prison without parole." Mathews said, "I understand."

Judge Steelman had been planning to try the case here starting on Jan. 23 using a Nashville jury.

Sgt. Chapin was shot and killed near a pawn shop on Brainerd Road on April 4, 2011.

Prosecutors said members of the Chapin family went along with the plea deal.

Sgt. Chapin left behind a wife, son and daughter.

A large number of police officers were in the courtroom for the guilty plea, including Lorin Johnston, who was shot by Mathews during the same incident.

Mathews is a former Colorado parolee whose family had moved to Chattanooga after he skipped out of a halfway house and committed several new armed robberies.

The plea deal will end a lawsuit that defense attorneys Lee Davis and Bryan Hoss filed in Federal Court seeking to have prosecutor Steve Neff testify at the sentencing phase of the Mathews trial. Also in that case, the attorneys asked Federal Judge Sandy Mattice to testify.

Both prosecutor Neff and Judge Mattice declined to testify.   

District Attorney Bill Cox and chief assistant Neal Pinkston handled the case for the state.

Police had arrived quickly on the scene of the holdup at the U.S. Money Shop near Big Lots. Sgt. Chapin was among those following Mathews on a narrow road nearby. Apparently, they exchanged shots and Mathews dropped the gun he was using. However, he then reached for a second gun that he had on him and he shot Sgt. Chapin in the forehead.

Mathews was captured a short distance away by a nearby resident, who forced him to kneel until police arrived. 


Home In Apison Heavily Damaged By Fire On Tuesday

A home was damaged by fire Tuesday evening. At  6 p.m. , a neighbor called 911 reporting a house fire at 4724 Wesleyan Road. The Tri-Community Volunteer Fire Department responded and arrived on the scene reporting 25% of the house was involved with fire. Firefighters quickly established a water line to get the fire under control. Other Tri-Community firefighters ... (click for more)

Shannon Whitfield Wins Republican Nomination For Walker County Sole Commissioner

Shannon Whitfield defeated Mike Peardon on Tuesday in the race for the Republican nominee for Walker County sole commissioner. Mr. Whitfield, who is president of Whitfield Oil won by a margin of 4,456 to 1,473. Both local businessmen announced prior to the first of the year that they would seek the post. Bebe Heiskell, the incumbent, says she will run as an Independent ... (click for more)

Colonel Enicks Is Turning Out Leaders At Red Bank High School

I am a former teacher and football coach at Red Bank High School. I have been a witness to the great things that happen at Red Bank High School.  The teaching staff has a great mixture of experience and promising new teachers.   Dr. Robertson, the principal, is a great man and a wonderful role model for students. He shows up the same way every day and his consistency ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Hot Rod’s Catfish Dinner

It could well be the best part of playing a prank is in the delicious moments until your “fish” takes the hook. So yesterday afternoon, as I tried repeatedly to talk to a man I haven’t spoken to in 27 years, rather than leave my name I popped off the Happy Birthday song in a snappy, loud way and then ended it with a simple, “Call me,” adding my number. John “Hot Rod” Talley spent ... (click for more)

Steventon, Cady Lead McCallie To 1-0 Division II-AA State Baseball Win

LEBANON, Tenn. – Rested and ready, McCallie junior Palmer Steventon pitched like the game’s outcome depended on his strong left arm. It did. Steventon, who nursed a slight shoulder problem through an idle final weekend to the regular season, fired a five-hit shutout, teammate Ethan Cady produced the only run with a fifth inning RBI double and the Blue Tornado posted a ... (click for more)

Meigs County Upends Silverdale In Class A Softball

MURFREESBORO – The Meigs County Lady Tigers have been on a collision course with the Silverdale Lady Seahawk softball team all season and they finally got a chance to play – in the opening round of the Class A state tournament here at the StarPlex Field Number 4. By far the two best teams in that classification, the Lady Tigers claimed round one with a come-from-behind 3-1 ... (click for more)