Go Ahead And Let The State Take Over Failing Schools

Monday, July 17, 2017

I read Roy's column regarding a "state takeover" of five local schools. Having worked in public education for 30 years here in Chattanooga and Hamilton County before retiring in 2001, I have listened to officials from the state department talk about "taking over" what they call failing schools beginning around 1997.

If a bank gets in trouble or a business starts to collapse, a takeover there means something entirely different than a school takeover. Receivers are appointed by the court and a carefully drawn plan for recovery is put into force.

For 20 years politicians and state bureaucrats have been pushing the ultimate takeover action down the road. The same schools here in Hamilton County are the essentially same ones identified for state action many years ago but the students and staff are essentially different. So what's the problem here?

My thinking is go ahead state folks, show us what you can do. What magic formula do you have that you haven't shared with local administrators for the last 20 years? And if there is one why haven't you shared it until now?

Again, my thinking is this new crew of pols and many of the same folks that bravely man the desks in the State Department of Education in Nashville don't have anything new any more than those folks over the last 20 years.

Sure, there are private firms that come up with ideas about operating the schools. Yes, folks with good intentions apply to operate specialized charter schools. The same thing has happened all over the country. But why hasn't there been any huge wave of success that has swept the education world and turned these many schools around?

The answer is not as complicated as we've been led to believe by the so-called experts. For the first half of the Twentieth Century the American family valued an education and saw it as the door to opportunity and success. Simply put, an education had great value. And it took hard work, dedication and endurance to get one.

Enter the Great Society and all of its entitlements including an education. But just giving one an education, or rather holding classes and enacting compulsory attendance laws forcing young people to attend class hasn't worked for many. Getting a useful education that leads to successful employment is not given. It's earned and worked for and the family has to place the highest value on achievement.

Until this American value is once again more than just talk and blustering, things will go on as they have.

Ralph Miller



Why The Ed Johnson Memorial Matters To Me, A Libertarian

I have seen a lot of responses to the question of whether or not our city and county should financially support the Ed Johnson Memorial at the Walnut Street bridge. Some fully support government pitching in and some say that private individuals and civic organizations should pitch in. Both are correct.  Our city has become a very sought after place to live. From our hometown ... (click for more)

Thankful Corker Stood Up To Pentagon Spending

I’m writing to thank Senator Bob Corker for his principled stand on the issue of Pentagon spending.  Earlier this week, Senator Corker voted against a Pentagon policy bill that would authorize nearly $700 billion in spending. This is a brave stance for a Republican, as Pentagon spending has become the new “third rail” in federal budgeting. Vote against a single dollar for ... (click for more)

Lone Survivor Of Lookout Valley Massacre Says He Is 100% Sure Morse Was One Of Shooters; Detective Tells Of Retrieving Guns

The lone survivor of a massacre at a Lookout Valley trailer park on April 9, 2014, testified Wednesday that he is 100 percent sure that Derek Morse was one of the two shooters. Matthew Callam said he was thrown off initially by the fact that Morse had facial hair at the time, but he said when he was shown a recent photo of Morse soon after the incident "it was like I was looking ... (click for more)

3 Firefighters Carry Unresponsive Woman From Burning Lookout Valley Home

Three Chattanooga firefighters early Wednesday morning carried an unresponsive woman from a burning house in Lookout Valley.   At  3:08  a.m., firefighters were dispatched to a house fire at 111 Centro Ave.The 911 dispatchers told the responding firefighters that someone may be trapped inside. Upon arrival, the firefighters observed smoke and flames coming ... (click for more)

Impressive Signal Mountain Whips Red Bank, 3-0

The Signal Mountain Lady Eagles have one of the better volleyball teams in town this fall and it’s no surprise that they are unbeaten in district play. They proved just how good they are Tuesday evening in Red Bank’s Susan Ingram Thurman Gymnasium as they needed about 50 minutes to beat the Lionettes for the second time this season. Set scores were 25-6, 25-7 and 25-15. ... (click for more)

PREVIEW: Georgia Bulldogs Face Mississippi State In Athens Saturday Evening

One of the best matchups of the weekend might be No. 11 Georgia and No. 17 Mississippi State on Saturday evening in Athens, GA, as they both look to hand the opponent their first loss of the season. For the second week in a row, Georgia's Bulldogs play another Bulldogs team. Both teams are 3-0. Both have had a strong win over a ranked opponent — at least at the time they played. ... (click for more)