Don't Automatically Restore Firearms To Veterans At Risk- And Response (2)

Friday, March 17, 2017

In the March 17 article, "Graves Votes To Start Cleaning House At The VA," Rep. Graves vocalizes his support for H.R. 1181, a bill that could automatically restore firearms to tens of thousands of veterans who may pose a danger to themselves. 

H.R. 1181 is the latest item on the National Rifle Association’s legislative checklist. Predictably, Congressman Graves and his colleagues are doing the NRA's bidding and ramming the bill through without due diligence.  The bill was passed by committee without a proper hearing, and the bill's current language is so broad that even its co-sponsor, Rep. Phil Roe (R-TN), cannot adequately explain its mechanisms. 

In its present form, HR 1181 could retroactively remove individuals from the National Instant Background Checks System. Given the high rate of suicide among veterans, retroactively removing individuals from NICS could put veterans in danger. Additionally, in its present form, HR 1181 does not outline a process to determine whether retroactively removed individuals are, in fact, at risk of harming themselves or others.   

Members on both sides of the aisle have acknowledged past flaws in the fiduciary process the Department of Veterans Affairs used to enter veterans into NICS.  But the blanket restoration of guns to our veterans at risk of suicide is not the solution. Rep. Graves should know better.  

Andrew Patrick
Coalition to Stop Gun Violence 

* * * 

Mr. Patrick is right. 

As the Vietnam conflict was winding down, we were stationed in a military town where planeloads of military persons were returning home on a continuous bases. All I can say is, not everyone who goes away to war or conflict is capable of leaving either behind them and turning back into the mild-mannered Clark Kent when they return home. There are domestic violence issues (don't think the term was around during that time), child abuse issues, self-destructive behaviors and other anti-social problems to be considered, alongside the issue of suicide Mr. Patrick mentions.  

Whereas those things committed on the battlefield are often celebrated during war and conflict, society will quickly and without question want to lock them in cages when committed at home and on peaceful soil. Some tend to forget, however, that just as easily as wars and conflicts produce heroes they can just as easily create monsters. And there's no way of telling which is likely to be lurking in the shadows or when or if one might strike.  

Brenda Washington 

* * * 

Arbitrarily restricting the rights of a group of individuals for some perceived problem, a problem with about as much proof as the moon being made of green cheese, is about like restricting the rights of a group of people because of the amount of melanin in their skin isn't it. 

For those who are so appalled at the incidence of veteran suicides, maybe they need to look at the way they're treated. We take young men and women, teach them to kill bad guys and make loud noises, then escort them to the gate and say "Thanks. See ya." Then they have to beg and plead for the services promised them for going off to war so the rest of us can go about out merry little lives. 

It's just my personal opinion, but anyone, anyone, who would advocate restricting the rights and the promised services of our veterans should live under the same conditions veterans have for a while. A few months or years ought to do. 

Look in the mirror and ask yourselves "What have I done today to make this world a better place?" 

Vicki Rodgers
Nine Mile, Tn.



True Revenue Situation

My honorable and respected friend Roy Exum tells us again today, “It has been 12 years since the county fathers have approved a tax increase ... .” I’ll take his word for that, but want some more information. “No tax increase for 12 years” is just the chorus; I want to hear the rest of the song, the specific verses that really tell the tale. The fact is, although Roy’s bare ... (click for more)

Send Your Opinions To Chattanoogan.com

We welcome your opinions at Chattanoogan.com. Email to  news@chattanoogan.com . We require your real first and last name and contact information. There is no word limit, but if your article is too long you may lose your reader. Please focus more on issues than personal attacks. (click for more)

Judge Walter Williams May Go Back On The Bench As Administrative Hearing Officer

One of the city's most colorful judges may go back on the bench. The City Council on Tuesday is set to vote on the nomination of former City Court Judge Walter Williams as administrative hearing officer - a new city position. The law license of the former judge was transferred to disability inactive status in August of 2015 after he suffered a stroke early in the year.  ... (click for more)

Body Believed To Be That Of McCallie Student Jackson Standefer Recovered In Colorado River

A body believed to be that of a McCallie School student who was swept away in a creek in the Grand Canyon was recovered on Friday. The Grand Canyon Regional Communications Center said it was notified by a commercial river trip that they located a body on the Colorado River at River Mile 152. Park rangers responded and recovered the body, which was transported to the rim ... (click for more)

Morgan, Smith, Parrott Pace Lady Pounders Past Bearettes 6-0

Maybe Central softball coach LeeAnne Shurette won’t nag her Lady Pounders so much in the coming days. Central collected eight hits, including two-run singles by Tatum Morgan and Janara Smith, on Friday to back Brooke Parrott’s three-hitter and the Lady Pounders defeated Bradley Central 6-0 in the East Hamilton tournament at The Summit. “Shurette has been nagging, maybe ... (click for more)

McCallie Earns 3-1 Soccer Win Over Rival Baylor

When his team needed him the most, McCallie senior Drew Viscomi did what he does best. Two minutes after the Blue Tornado allowed an equalizer to rival Baylor in the Division II Mid-East Region soccer match on the Red Raiders’ home field, Viscomi’s strike put his team back on top. Five minutes later, the All-American and school single-season scoring leader ... (click for more)