Supreme Court Reviews Use Of Self-Defense When Engaged In Unlawful Activity

Tuesday, November 21, 2017
The Supreme Court of Tennessee clarified the law of self-defense when the person making the claim is engaged in unlawful activity at the time the need for self-defense occurred. This clarification is important because some trial courts have not allowed defendants to assert self-defense when it appeared they were engaged in unlawful activity at the time they used force to defend themselves.  
 
In the case before the Court, the defendant alleged that he was acting in self-defense when he fired his handgun, which he possessed illegally, toward a group of men standing in front of a convenience store in Memphis.
  He struck a young child inside the store. At his trial, the trial court instructed the jury on self-defense, but determined that the jury should decide whether the defendant was engaged in unlawful activity.  According to the jury instructions, the defendant’s self-defense theory would fail if he was engaged in unlawful activity. 
 
The jury rejected the defendant’s self-defense theory and convicted him of attempted voluntary manslaughter as a lesser-included offense of attempted second degree murder; employing a firearm during the commission of a dangerous felony; five counts of aggravated assault; and one count of assault as a lesser-included offense of aggravated assault. The Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed his convictions, but ruled that the trial court erred in its jury instructions on self-defense. The defendant appealed to the Tennessee Supreme Court. 
 
In its analysis, the Supreme Court outlined the history of self-defense law in Tennessee, focusing on the common law duty to retreat when confronted with unlawful force, which the legislature initially abandoned when it codified the law of the self-defense in 1989. The legislature later added conditions on the statutory privilege not to retreat in 2007.  In this case, the Supreme Court faced the question of whether the statutory language, “not engaged in unlawful activity,” was a prerequisite for asserting self-defense or applied only to the privilege not to retreat.  The Supreme Court determined that the phrase “not engaged in unlawful activity” in the self-defense statute was a condition on the privilege not to retreat. The Court also held that the trial court, and not the jury, should make the threshold determination of whether the State showed there was clear and convincing evidence that the defendant was engaged in unlawful activity when he used force in an alleged self-defense situation.
 
Based on the facts in this case, the Supreme Court held that the defendant, who admitted to being a felon in possession of a handgun, was engaged in unlawful activity. The Supreme Court also ruled that the trial court’s jury instructions were erroneous because the instructions left the determination of unlawful activity to the jury. However, the Court found the error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.  
 
The Supreme Court also ruled against the defendant on jury instructions related to the possession of a firearm as a lesser-included offense; adequate notice of an underlying felony; the defense of necessity; and the sufficiency of proof to support his conviction for assault of the convenience store owner, who was behind bulletproof glass when the shots were fired. The Court affirmed the defendant’s convictions. 
 
To read the opinion, authored by Justice Roger A. Page, visit the opinions section of TNcourts.gov.


Circadian Consulting, Barnett Jones Wilson Join INCubator Program

The INCubator in the Hamilton County Business Development Center is an "entrepreneurial sanctuary," providing space and support services for a range of up and coming businesses. With nearly 600 graduates in 30 years, and the ability to house up to 70 businesses at a time, the INCubator's businesses include those new on the scene, recent graduates launching into the local market ... (click for more)

Boyd Veal To Represent Town Of Signal Mountain On WWTA Board

Signal Mountain Town Manager Boyd Veal has been appointed by the Town Council to serve on the WWTA Board. He replaces Dick Gee who has moved outside of the town limits of Signal Mountain.   Mr. Veal has over 25 years of experience on Signal Mountain.  He began his career as a patrol officer and rose through the ranks to become chief of police in 2004.  He ... (click for more)

Mother Of 15-Year-Old Killed By His Father Said McElrath Had Been Acting "Manic"

The mother of a 15-year-old boy who was killed by his father said Michael McElrath had been acting "manic" in the days leading up to the tragic incident in Hixson on Aug. 18. Judge Alex McVeigh bound a charge of criminal homicide against McElrath, a former jail officer, to the Grand Jury. He is charged in the death of Dylan McElrath, who was a sophomore at Hixson High School. ... (click for more)

UT Board Considering Randy Boyd As Interim UT President

Randy Boyd, who was among the Republican finalists for the governor nomination, is being considered as interim president at the University of Tennessee. Dr. Joe DiPietro this week announced that Nov. 21 will be his last day on the job. The University of Tennessee Board of Trustees are to meet next week and consider the Boyd appointment. Mr. Boyd, a UT alumnus, would ... (click for more)

Arming Teachers With Guns Will Be Too Dangerous - And Response (3)

Arming teachers with guns in the classroom, as Bill Lee proposes, would be the single most dangerous thing to happen to students in Tennessee history. Students and teachers in close proximity to loaded firearms daily? Across this state, in middle schools alone, there are probably hundreds of student/teacher conflicts a day. What if a student got hold of gun in a struggle with ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Who Is This ‘New Voice’?

It’s easy for me to say that I either know, or know about, almost every person running in November for the state legislature. Yet when I describe Lemon Williams as the most exciting of the bunch, that’s because he's the only guy I had never heard of when he picked up his qualifying papers. He just turned out the best political aspirant I have had a conversation with in the last ... (click for more)