Prolific Flim-Flam Artists May Have Hit Multiple Stores In Dalton

Tuesday, November 21, 2017
Annise Timte Smith
Annise Timte Smith

The Dalton Police Department has warrants for the arrest of Annise Timte Smith and Howard Terez Fuller, both from the Atlanta metro area, on charges related to a “quick change” scam that ripped off area stores of cash after the suspects tricked a cashier into giving an incorrect amount of change from a purchase. An investigation showed the pair tried the scam multiple times while in Dalton and they are suspected of perpetrating the same scam at other stores over a three day period, along the I-75 corridor between Atlanta and Illinois. Now investigators are looking for other businesses that may have been victimized.

The incidents in Dalton took place on Oct. 9. After the Dalton Police Department issued a press release on Oct. 12 about a similar scam that took place at the Walnut Avenue Chick-fil-A, a manager from the Dollar General store at 2524 Cleveland Highway contacted police to report being ripped off by two black male suspects, one of whom resembled the suspect in the Chick-fil-A case. The two suspects also attempted the same scam at the Dollar General store at 101 West Walnut Avenue, but they were unsuccessful in fooling the cashier. Investigators determined that the Chick-fil-A incident and the Dollar General incidents were not related.

In the Dollar General incidents, one suspect, later identified as Howard Terez Fuller, 27, of Decatur would act as a look-out while the second suspect, Annise Timte Smith, 29, of Lithonia would attempt to purchase a cheap piece of merchandise with a $100 bill. Smith would then engage the clerk in conversation either about applying for a job or flirting. As the clerk began counting out the change, Smith requested the $100 bill back saying he had exact change. In the case of the Cleveland Highway incident, the confused clerk was tricked into giving back the original bill and also the store’s money in the form of change. Smith and Fuller would then leave with their own money, the store’s money, and the merchandise.

While investigating these incidents, Dalton investigators saw a bulletin posted on a national crime intelligence service from police in Effingham, Il., alerting law enforcement that two men from the Atlanta area had been arrested there Oct. 11 after performing the same scam at five Dollar General stores in their area.

After confirming that the men in custody in Illinois were also the men suspected in Dalton, DPD investigators canvassed Dollar General stores and other locations throughout the city and county and discovered that Fuller and Smith had visited eight Dollar General stores in our area on Oct. 9, and also two CVS pharmacies. They attempted the scam at five of the stores and were successful at the 2417 Airport Road Dollar General, the 2524 Cleveland Highway Dollar General, and the CVS at 2791 Cleveland Highway. In each case, they left with a small amount of merchandise, approximately $95 in the store’s money, and their original $100 bill. The pair traveled in a white 2012 Nissan Sentra.

The Dalton Police Department has warrants for the arrest of Howard Fuller for 14 counts of criminal attempt to commit a misdemeanor, eighteen counts of conspiracy to commit a misdemeanor, and four counts of being party to a crime. The department also has warrants for Annise Smith’s arrest for two counts of theft by deception, two counts of theft by shoplifting, 14 counts of criminal attempt to commit a misdemeanor, and eighteen counts of conspiracy to commit a misdemeanor.

The Whitfield County Sheriff’s Office also has warrants for the pair for the scam at a CVS pharmacy in the county.

Both men bonded out in Illinois, and Fuller was later arrested in Rockdale County and is awaiting being brought to Whitfield County.

 Because the pair traveled from Atlanta to the Effingham, Il. area between Oct. 9 and their arrest on Oct. 11, investigators believe that they could have pulled the same scam numerous times in other cities along the I-75 corridor. Dalton investigators are asking anyone who believes they may have been victims of the same scam, particularly at Dollar General and CVS stores, to contact Detective Brian Shirley at 706-278-9085, extension 9189.

Howard Terez Fuller
Howard Terez Fuller


Woman Who Became Hospitalized After Drinking Well Water At Local Restaurant Files Class Action Suit

A woman who said she became hospitalized after drinking well water from a local restaurant has filed suit. Tina Rogers is suing the River Drifter Restaurant on Suck Creek Road and its owners, Charles and Renee Eich, as well as property owner Robert L. Newman. The Circuit Court complaint seeks to be declared a class action lawsuit and include others who became ill from drinking ... (click for more)

Boyd Says Commissioners Want Answers From Coppinger On Magistrate Payouts

County Commissioner Tim Boyd has written County Mayor Jim Coppinger saying he wants answers to questions raised about certain payouts to county magistrates. He said other commissioners who were at a Security and Corrections Committee meeting joined him in wanting the answers. Randy Russell, who was chief magistrate for eight years but was not retained, said other magistrates ... (click for more)

Jeff Styles, I Believe You - And Response (3)

I am glad that Jeff Styles presented the details of the event on his website.  Just because the government alleges a crime does not mean guilty. A criminal charge is an allegation by government. Sure, that allegation can be very serious, but the charge is still an unproven allegation until a court of law and Lady Justice has her review of the proof.  A person gets ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: ‘The Cake Is Baked’

If all goes well, and as expected, Hamilton County Chancellor Jeff Atherton will tell a group representing the Democratic Party not to ever again clutter his office or his courtroom with such a childish amount of political poppycock as will be brought on display tomorrow. The Democrats want to block Robin Smith, a longtime Republican stalwart, from becoming our next State Representative ... (click for more)

Volleyball Roundup: Red Bank Falls To Notre Dame, 3-0

Notre Dame beat Red Bank, 3-0, Wednesday in high school volleyball action with set scores of 25-17, 25-18 and 25-16. The Lady Lions (1-2) opened the season with a win against Grundy County and followed with a loss to Ooltewah before dropping Wednesday’s match to the Lady Irish. On Tuesday, Cleveland defeated rival Bradley Central 3-0 to open the Lady Raiders’ 2018 season. ... (click for more)

CCS, Red Bank, Ooltewah Volleyball Winners Tuesday

Chattanooga Christian, Red Bank and Ooltewah all won volleyball matches Tuesday with CCS improving to 2-0 with the 3-1 district win over Grace. Soddy Daisy defeated Hixson by a 3-1 final while Lookout Valley split a pair of matches, the Lady Yellow Jackets losing to Gordon Lee before defeating Ringgold. Soddy Daisy prevailed by scores of 25-10, 19-25, 25-8 and 25-21.  ... (click for more)