Legislative Survey Is Biased

  • Saturday, February 6, 2016

Recently I received a survey from Gerald McCormick. I started to complete the survey but discovered that numbers 2 and 3 were so biased that any results are invalid. The voucher question (#2) is extremely biased with a very leading question, 3 "Yes" responses framed in positive language, and one "No" framed in negative language. 

McCormick is using faulty data and sweeping generalizations to support his pro-voucher position. I am disappointed that he is playing politics with our tax dollars. 

Vouchers will undoubtedly be as effective a "reform" as the virtual school and achievement school district debacles have been.  

Vouchers must be opposed because:
1. Vouchers violate the state Constitution.
2. Vouchers result in the loss of accountability for taxpayer dollars. 
3. Private schools will "cherry-pick" students, taking only the best further degrading low performing schools. 
4. They will also take the money for a student then kick them out at their discretion.
5. There can be no valid data regarding success of vouchers because students who go to private schools are not required to take state mandated tests. 

Legislators should support public education and not subvert it.  

Click here for the survey.

Gil Highlander 

Hixson
 


Opinion
Kane V. Chuck In 2026
  • 4/24/2024

The question of who will be the standard bearer for the next four-year term of the Grand Old Party (GOP) for the 2026 Governors race in Tennessee is starting to take shape with the list of the ... more

Democratic View On Top Senate Issues: April 24, 2024
  • 4/24/2024

GOP agreement on Gov. Bill Lee’s $1.9 billion corporate handout could come today 9 a.m. CT Conference Committee — SB 2103 , Gov. Bill Lee’s single largest initiative in this year’s budget, ... more

Not Too Many More
  • 4/24/2024

Joe Biden observed Earth Day puffing about a $7 billion grant for solar projects benefiting low and middle income residents. This is a project of his Office of Environmental Justice and Dominion ... more