Supreme Court Opinion Intreprets Contact Renewal

Tuesday, November 20, 2012

In a unanimous opinion, the Tennessee Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that a subsequent contract between parties that shares provisions similar to a previous contract does not necessarily constitute a renewal of the earlier agreement.

At issue in BSG, LLC v. Check Velocity, Inc. is Check Velocity’s payment of fee residuals to BSG for referring clients to Check Velocity’s check re-presentment services. The parties executed two contracts that governed business they did together from early 2004 until early 2009. During that time, BSG referred Weight Watchers to Check Velocity. Check Velocity and Weight Watchers entered into an “Electronic Check Recovery Agreement” that expired June 29, 2007 although they continued to operate under the terms of that agreement until August 2008. During that time, Check Velocity continued to pay fee residuals to BSG. 

In August 2008, Check Velocity and Weight Watchers entered into a “Collection Services Agreement” in which Check Velocity continued to provide electronic re-presentment services but under different terms and with added responsibilities. Check Velocity ceased payments to BSG after September 15, 2008.

BSG filed a complaint alleging Check Velocity’s failure to pay fee residuals on the Weight Watchers contract constituted a breach of their 2006 agreement. 

The trial court awarded summary judgment in favor of Check Velocity, which was reversed by the Court of Appeals, holding that the 2008 agreement between Weight Watchers and Check Velocity was a renewal of the previous agreement and therefore required Check Velocity to pay BSG fee residuals under the terms of their 2006 agreement.

The Supreme Court reverses the Court of Appeals and affirms the trial court, holding today that, under the terms of the contract between BSG and Check Velocity, the second agreement between Weight Watchers and Check Velocity was not a renewal of the first agreement that would require Check Velocity to pay fee residuals to BSG.

To read the BSG, LLC v. CHECK VELOCITY, INC opinion, authored by Justice Janice M. Holder, visit ­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­ TNCourts.gov. 



Chief Justice Bivins Plans Ceremonial Swearing In With Governor Haslam

Tennessee Supreme Court Chief Justice Jeff Bivins will have a ceremonial swearing in with Governor Bill Haslam at 3:30 p.m. Thursday in the historic Supreme Court chambers within the Capitol. The event is open to the public.  Chief Justice Bivins was unanimously elected chief by the Court last month. He was appointed to the Court in 2014 by Governor Bill Haslam and was elected ... (click for more)

The CPR LifeWrap Launch Party Is Friday

The CPR LifeWrap launch party will be held Friday from 5-9 p.m at The Edney, 1100 Market St., 5th Floor.  CPR LifeWrap will be launching its Kickstarter campaign, as well as premiering its new video. There will be guest speakers, food, drinks, live music, mingling and door prizes. (click for more)

Naked Man Involved In Collision On Highway 111 Taken Into Custody

A naked man who was involved in a wreck on Highway 111 late Friday morning is facing numerous charges. At approximately 11:40 a.m., Hamilton County Sheriff deputies started to receive numerous reports that a vehicle was driving erratically on U.S. Highway 111 and that the driver was stopping his vehicle and at one point got out of his vehicle in a naked state. According to ... (click for more)

City Council Incumbents Anderson, Gilbert, Freeman, Hakeem Pick Up Papers Seeking Re-Election

Four City Council incumbents have picked up papers for the March 7 city election. The latest getting qualifying petitions are Russell Gilbert in District 5, Chris Anderson in District 7 and Yusuf Hakeem in District 9. Moses Freeman in District 8 picked up earlier. Anthony Byrd is a possible challenger. Former District 7 Councilman Manny Rico has already qualified. Others ... (click for more)

Chattanooga's Citizens Are The Best

Today, when I finished my shift, my wife and I had a rare kid-free time where she and I could enjoy a nice quiet dinner. So, when I left my extra job and she left her job, we met at a neat local place in St. Elmo. She and I had been looking forward to and planning this dinner all day. You see, between my work with the city of Chattanooga, my many hours of extra jobs, and our responsibilities ... (click for more)

My Garden In October

Just when you thought the weather would never break, the heat was on low this morning as Tide and I stepped from the house to study our October garden. Falling leaves and the dog’s dirty tennis balls aside, let’s praise the Lord that, as a new month dawns, we are still blessed with orchids and onions galore. The dog asks that I include the fact October is National Pet Adoption month ... (click for more)