Supreme Court Opinion Intreprets Contact Renewal

Tuesday, November 20, 2012

In a unanimous opinion, the Tennessee Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that a subsequent contract between parties that shares provisions similar to a previous contract does not necessarily constitute a renewal of the earlier agreement.

At issue in BSG, LLC v. Check Velocity, Inc. is Check Velocity’s payment of fee residuals to BSG for referring clients to Check Velocity’s check re-presentment services. The parties executed two contracts that governed business they did together from early 2004 until early 2009. During that time, BSG referred Weight Watchers to Check Velocity. Check Velocity and Weight Watchers entered into an “Electronic Check Recovery Agreement” that expired June 29, 2007 although they continued to operate under the terms of that agreement until August 2008. During that time, Check Velocity continued to pay fee residuals to BSG. 

In August 2008, Check Velocity and Weight Watchers entered into a “Collection Services Agreement” in which Check Velocity continued to provide electronic re-presentment services but under different terms and with added responsibilities. Check Velocity ceased payments to BSG after September 15, 2008.

BSG filed a complaint alleging Check Velocity’s failure to pay fee residuals on the Weight Watchers contract constituted a breach of their 2006 agreement. 

The trial court awarded summary judgment in favor of Check Velocity, which was reversed by the Court of Appeals, holding that the 2008 agreement between Weight Watchers and Check Velocity was a renewal of the previous agreement and therefore required Check Velocity to pay BSG fee residuals under the terms of their 2006 agreement.

The Supreme Court reverses the Court of Appeals and affirms the trial court, holding today that, under the terms of the contract between BSG and Check Velocity, the second agreement between Weight Watchers and Check Velocity was not a renewal of the first agreement that would require Check Velocity to pay fee residuals to BSG.

To read the BSG, LLC v. CHECK VELOCITY, INC opinion, authored by Justice Janice M. Holder, visit ­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­­ TNCourts.gov. 



Miller & Martin Practices, Attorneys Recognized In 2017 Chambers USA

Chambers and Partners has recognized Miller & Martin in the 2017 Chambers USA: America's Leading Lawyers for Business report as a leading law firm in the practice areas of Labor & Employment, Corporate/M&A and Litigation: General Commercial, and also recognizes six of the firm’s attorneys. Individual lawyers are ranked on the basis of their legal knowledge and experience, ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Chamber Calendar Of Events May 30-June 2

Thursday, June 1 Downtown Chamber Council Meeting 7:30  - 9 a.m. Bessie Smith Hall: 200 E M L King Blvd. Speaker: Jay Raynor, Defoor Brothers Topic: City Center Development Join the Downtown Council for networking and breakfast from 7:30 - 8 a.m., with the program lasting from 8 - 9 a.m.   $15   East Ridge Chamber Council Meeting 11:45 a.m. - ... (click for more)

Richard Anderson, 29, Struck And Killed While Trying To Cross Highway 153

Richard Anderson II, 29, was killed Friday night, while trying to cross Highway 153.   Chattanooga Police responded at 11:36 p.m. to a traffic crash involving a pedestrian struck.   A Honda Civic driven by Kelsey Hamilton, 20, was traveling southbound on Highway 153 in the middle lane with other traffic in adjacent lanes.   Mr. Anderson, wearing ... (click for more)

Eppard, 32, Charged With Aggravated Statutory Rape After 17-Year-Old He Was Living With Has Baby

Police have charged 32-year-old Anthony John Eppard with aggravated statutory rape after the 17-year-old girl he was living with had a baby. Officers were called to a civil dispute on Hillsview Drive on March 8. It was then found that the girl was living at the residence. She could not supply the name of next of kin or a legal guardian. The girl was placed in state custody, ... (click for more)

Silence Ain’t Golden Anymore

There are times – moments – in life that you never forget. That night in 1972, sleeping over at my buddy Bart’s house, was one of them. We had been to a middle school concert and his big brother was in the band (very cool stuff for a 14-year-old!) and as we lay on the floor in our sleeping bags in Bart’s room he said he wanted to play a record that his brother listened to. And, ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Prove No Improvement

The startling news that this year’s standardized testing was wasted on graduating seniors across Tennessee is most unsettling. This week it was learned the test results, which were to represent 10 percent of our seniors’ final grades, was a total bust. Coupled with last year’s gargantuan testing failure – the whole effort had to be scrapped -- it is now becoming realized that for ... (click for more)