State Supreme Court Rules Re-Filed Malpractice Lawsuit Must Follow New State Laws

Thursday, October 4, 2012
 In a unanimous opinion, the Tennessee Supreme Court ruled that a re-filed malpractice lawsuit must follow state statutes in effect at the time of re-filing.

In 2006, Curtis Myers suffered a stroke and was treated by various healthcare providers. The next year, he filed a complaint in Shelby County Circuit Court alleging medical malpractice against healthcare providers who had treated him.

The original lawsuit was pending when the state legislature enacted new requirements (Tennessee Code Annotated sections 29-26-121 and 122) related to medical malpractice actions in Tennessee. The new laws went into effect on Oct. 1, 2008, and were amended on July 1, 2009.

On Oct. 21, 2008, Mr. Myers dismissed his lawsuit and re-filed it on September 30, 2009. The defendants moved to dismiss the complaint based on Mr. Myers’ failure to comply with the new state laws which required pre-suit notice be given to the defendants and that the plaintiff file a certificate of good faith. The trial court denied the motion ruling that the plaintiff’s original suit constituted substantial compliance with the statutes and that extraordinary cause existed to excuse compliance with the requirements of one of the statutes. The Court of Appeals reversed the trial court.

Today, the Tennessee Supreme Court, in an opinion authored by Justice Sharon G. Lee, ordered that the complaint be dismissed. The Court noted that the statutory requirements of providing pre-suit notice to the defendants and filing a certificate of good faith are mandatory and not subject to substantial compliance and that Mr. Myers failed to demonstrate extraordinary cause for non-compliance.

To read the Curtis Myers v. AMISUB, Inc. et al. opinion authored by Justice Sharon G. Lee, visit .

Supreme Court Determines Rental Car Qualifies As Uninsured Motor Vehicle

The Tennessee Supreme Court has determined that a car rented from a national self-insured car rental agency qualifies as an “uninsured motor vehicle” for purposes of an insurance claim filed by a Williamson County man. This case involves a lawsuit file by Edward Martin after he was struck by a vehicle driven by Gregory Powers, a patron of the bar Mr. Martin owns. Mr. Martin ... (click for more)

Southern Heritage Bank Continues Local Deposit Growth

For the sixth consecutive year, Southern Heritage Bank has grown its market share of deposits in Bradley County, according to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation annual summary of insured deposits. Retaining second place, Southern Heritage reported 15.6 percent ($233.7 million) in local deposit market share just behind First Tennessee Bank’s 15.7 percent ($235.1 million).  ... (click for more)

Howard Simmons, 47, Shot And Killed In St. Elmo Monday Morning; Police Interview Person Of Interest

Howard Simmons, 47, was shot and killed in St. Elmo Monday morning. Police said they had interviewed a person of interest in the slaying. Chattanooga Police at 8:30 a.m. responded to a person shot at the 5000 block of Florida Ave. Upon police arrival the victim, Simmons, had already succumbed to his injuries. Ms. Simmons suffered at least one gunshot wound. At this time ... (click for more)

Erlanger To Open Cancer Center On Gunbarrel Road At East Campus

Work is set to begin soon on construction of a new Cancer Center by Erlanger Health System at its Gunbarrel Road East Campus. Erlanger is joining with a development firm, Chatt East 3 LLC of Alabama, on the four-story project located just south of Women's East Hospital on a wooded five-acre tract. Erlanger will be leasing the bottom three floors at a rate of $16.05 per square ... (click for more)

October Is Breast Cancer Awareness Month

Picture a sold-out baseball game at Wrigley Field or Nationals Park packed with 40,000 fans. That image represents roughly the same number of women and men who die from breast cancer each year.  In Tennessee alone, an estimated 900 women will die from the disease in 2016. It is a sad statistic, but there is some good news: thanks to early detection and improved treatments, ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Testerman Forum

I badly misjudged how long it would take me to do my “early voting.” I was in-and-out in no time so I got to the Hamilton County School Board’s agenda meeting well enough beforehand to have an “educational forum” with board member David Testerman. If you haven’t noticed, forums and summits and “community enlightenment” groups are the new rage and, as my friend David laughed, “They ... (click for more)