City Council Rejects Alternate Redistricting Plan By Black Leaders

Okays Plan With 3 Majority-Minority Districts, 1 Swing District

Tuesday, December 13, 2011

The City Council on Tuesday night rejected a last-minute redistricting plan by black leaders and instead unanimously approved one that was tentatively agreed on last week.

Joe Rowe, NAACP leader, said the new plan would give four majority-minority districts - Districts 5, 7, 8 and 9.

He said the council's plan only included three majority-minority districts.

Mr. Rowe said the council plan may run afoul of the federal Voting Rights Act, saying it represents "retrogression" on minority representation.

Councilman Manny Rico hit the new plan, saying, "You talk about gerrymandering. To me it doesn't make sense to make it like that."

He said it would have Councilman Andrae McGary part of a district he had never represented before.

Councilman Rico said redistricting "should be a race-neutral process."

He said, "It's not fair to the people we have worked with for years."

Councilman Rico also said white people had made many overtures to help blacks. He said, "This race thing is getting out of hand, and I resent it."

Councilman Russell Gilbert disagreed, saying, "Racism is still there. We have not arrived."

Councilman Jack Benson said he was "real disappointed in what you've thrown before us. You've just gutted my district."

Councilwoman Carol Berz said, "This would take the heart out of a project that has been going on for a long time. The assumption here is that white people think alike and black people think alike - and that's an insult."

She said the new plan was "very gerrymandered."

Councilman Peter Murphy said Mr. Rowe told him earlier he wanted to keep majority-minority districts of at least 60 percent black voting age population. He said the new plan drops below that.

Mr. Rowe said redistricting should be about "building for the future, not holding onto the past."

City Attorney Mike McMahan said the council's plan is similar to one in 1990 when he said there were also three majority-minority districts and a swing district.

Absent from the meeting - on a city visit to Germany - were council members Pam Ladd and Andrae McGary.

Others attending the meeting included Rep. Tommie Brown and former school board member Sherman Matthews.


McCormick Says Tax Increase Is Last Resort For Transportation Infrastructure

House Majority Leader Gerald McCormick released the following statement to clarify previous remarks regarding transportation infrastructure funding: "I would like to take the opportunity to clarify my comments made to the Hamilton County Pachyderm Club yesterday regarding Tennessee’s transportation infrastructure. In no way am I advocating for our state to take on debt to fund ... (click for more)

Medical Examiner Changes Opinion In Case In Which Teen Lost Baby After Beating By Boyfriend

Hamilton County Medical Examiner Dr. James Metcalfe testified Tuesday that he had changed his findings in the death of a teen's foetus after she said she was beaten by her boyfriend. Dr. Metcalfe first listed the death of "Promise Jones" as a homicide due to blunt force injury.  He said he later determined that it could have been as the result of another cause - placental ... (click for more)

Why Chattanooga Should Stop Granting Apartment Complex PILOTs - And Response

A new report indicates why Chattanooga and Hamilton County officials do not need to extend PILOTs to apartment complex developers. Demand is high, therefore developers will continue to build to meet the demand without PILOTs. What is truly needed in the Chattanooga metroplex is low-income affordable housing. “Homeownership Drops to Lowest Level in Decades” ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Gun Control? Accuracy!

When President Barack Obama responded to the tragic killing of nine people who were worshiping at their beloved Emanuel AME Church in Charleston, S.C., last month, he immediately blamed the gun, saying, “We don't have all the facts, but we do know that once again, innocent people were killed in part because someone who wanted to inflict harm had no trouble getting their hand on ... (click for more)

Dalton Edges Stuart Heights To Conclude Unbeaten Regular Season

The Dalton Dolphins had several key goals when the 2015 Chattanooga Area Swim League season began on the first day of June and they can put a big check mark by the first one, which was to go undefeated in the ever-competitive Blue division. They accomplished that goal before dark on Monday as they defeated a much-improved Stuart Heights squad by a 404-386 final that may have ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Hosts Nashville Friday In NPSL Playoffs

Chattanooga will host this weekend's National Premier Soccer League Southeast Conference playoffs. There are two semifinal matches on Friday with the two winners meeting in the Championship match the following night. “We’re very proud of the team for winning home field advantage,” said board member Krue Brock. “Now that every game is a must-win situation, it will be a big help ... (click for more)